Caliban Darklock wrote this in the early morning:
Here’s my top twelve in rough order.Â
- Melinda Doolittle
- Chris Sligh
- Blake Lewis
- LaKisha Jones
- Chris Richardson
- Sabrina Sloan
- Phil Stacey
- Gina Glocksen
- Jordin Sparks
- Brandon Rogers
- Stephanie Edwards
- Jared Cotter
Melinda’s my choice for winner this year, with Chris Sligh actually deserving to win but coming in second.
Blake Lewis will round out the top three. This is tentative. Blake Lewis may actually win. If so, Chris Sligh will still come in second.
LaKisha Jones will not make the final three. She’s the “we wuz robbed” competitor this year: she deserves to get farther than she will actually get.
Chris Richardson and Sabrina Sloan are solid top six competitors, but they do face some competition up at the top end of the rest. Â
I thought Phil was a major force in the competition, but he hasn’t really grown in the past couple weeks, and the rest of the competitors have. I don’t think he’ll make the final month, but he should still be around next week. Â
Gina Glocksen is much more interesting as a competitor now that she’s pulled out the Amy Lee stylings, but I think her song last night was just a bit too much for her. If she’s smart enough to scale it back a bit, and I think she is, she should get close to the top six and may actually displace someone if she grows a bit.
Jordin Sparks and Brandon Rogers aren’t even remotely top six material. I like them just fine, but they’re not top drawer. I’m also not sure why Simon and considers Stephanie Edwards a major force in the competition. I don’t agree. Of course, Simon’s usually right, but I’ll stick with my own gut on this one. And Jared Cotter is only making the top twelve because there are twelve of them.
Antonella Barba and Haley Scarnato are almost definitely out tonight; Sanjaya Malakar and Sundance Head from the men’s side. However, these four are just the worst half of the bottom eight, and one or more of them could stick around another week or two by displacing one of the better half. Sanjaya and Antonella, in particular, are popular enough to displace Jared or Stephanie respectively. Even Sundance has some inexplicable following of tone-deaf retards.